When an appliance breaks down, the financial decision between repair and replacement involves more than comparing the repair estimate to a new appliance's price tag. Making an informed choice requires considering several factors.
Understanding True Costs
A repair estimate is straightforward, but replacement costs extend beyond the purchase price. Factor in delivery fees, installation costs, removal of the old appliance, and potential modifications to accommodate a new model. A $1,200 appliance might cost $1,500 or more once it's actually running in your home.
The Value of Remaining Lifespan
Consider how much useful life your current appliance has left. A $400 repair on an 8-year-old refrigerator with another 7 years of expected life might be smarter than replacing it. That same repair on a 15-year-old model might not make sense.
Energy Efficiency Calculations
Older appliances typically use more energy than new ones. Calculate potential energy savings by comparing your current appliance's estimated annual operating cost (check the EnergyGuide label if you still have it) to a new ENERGY STAR model. Over 10 years, $75 in annual savings equals $750—real money that affects the repair-vs-replace equation.
Quality and Feature Considerations
Not all appliances are equal. A high-quality appliance that's provided years of reliable service may deserve repair investment, while a basic model might not warrant significant spending. Also consider whether you'd want to upgrade features—though be wary of paying for capabilities you won't actually use.
Getting an Honest Opinion
We believe in transparent advice. After diagnosing your appliance, we'll share not just the repair cost but our honest assessment of whether the repair makes financial sense. Sometimes the best service is helping you avoid putting money into the wrong place.
What Our Customers Say About Our Appliance Repair Services
"Nick came out within 24 hours to diagnose a problem with our Bosch dishwasher. He quickly diagnosed the problem, listening carefully to the history we gave. He recommended that it would probably be more financially expedient to replace it. We asked him to recommend a brand and a place to buy it. He even looked it up online for us."
— Kathleen W., West Michigan
"Toby was AWESOME! I called UDG about my leaking dishwasher. The appointment setup was quick and simple. Toby arrived the next day and replaced my water supply line quickly and efficiently. Highly recommend. Thanks UDG!"
— Christian H., West Michigan
"We had an issue with the dishwasher and the guys at UDG came out and were very professional! I had texts as to arrival time and they were quick to figure out the problem, the new part was ordered and installed a day later (hard to do with Kitchen Aid appliances). We had another issue arise (completely unrelated)..."
— Gregory I., West Michigan
Schedule Your Appliance Repair Today
UDG Services provides fast, reliable appliance repair throughout West Michigan. As a Veteran-owned business, we bring military precision and dedication to every job—backed by our warranty and 90%+ first-visit completion rate.
Serving: Muskegon, Grand Haven, Norton Shores, Spring Lake, Fruitport, Holland, and communities throughout West Michigan.
Book a service call today—we'll take it from here.
Frequently Asked Questions About Appliance Repair vs. Replacement
How do I know if my appliance is worth repairing?
Use the 50% rule as a starting point: if the repair cost is more than 50% of the replacement cost and your appliance is past half its expected lifespan, replacement is often better. Also consider repair history, energy efficiency, and whether the appliance meets your current needs.
What is the average lifespan of common household appliances?
Dishwashers last 9-12 years, refrigerators 10-15 years, washing machines 10-14 years, dryers 10-13 years, and ranges/ovens 13-15 years. If your appliance is approaching these ages, factor that into your repair-or-replace decision.
Can a new appliance really save me money on energy costs?
Yes! Modern Energy Star-certified appliances can use 30% or more less energy and water than models from 10 years ago. Over the appliance's lifetime, these savings can significantly offset the purchase price.
Will a repair technician honestly tell me if I should replace instead of repair?
At UDG Services, we pride ourselves on honest assessments. Our technicians will always recommend what's in your best interest, even if that means suggesting replacement over repair. We'll explain the reasoning and even help you choose a new appliance if needed.
How quickly can UDG Services diagnose my appliance problem?
We typically arrive within 24 hours of your call and have a 90%+ first-visit completion rate. Most issues can be diagnosed and repaired on the first visit, saving you time and additional service fees.
What areas does UDG Services cover in West Michigan?
We serve Muskegon, Grand Haven, Norton Shores, Spring Lake, Fruitport, Holland, and surrounding communities throughout West Michigan with fast, reliable appliance repair services.




























